After last week's success with focaccia, we're moving on to Cookies! I don't think I've made cookies since Christmas. I know, it wasn't that long ago.....but honestly it feels longer. In Cookie Years (similar to dog years) it is closer to 2 years rather than (less than) 2 months. Much like the Mayan Calendar, I'm sure my Cookie Calendar will one day be discredited. But until then, 2 months will equal 2 years.
I hope this recipe is a winner. I could use a new cookie in my life. Oh sure, I've got my favourites, but there is always room for another favourite in my recipe box. Please note: I don't actually have a recipe box.....that sounds organized and nothing like my actual cookbook/recipe collecting self. Well, my inner me is totally organized and remembers where all my recipes are. Unfortunately, in real life my recipe box is my house. One day I'll get a handle on all the cookbooks and recipes everywhere. Not today though.....
Now let's get down to the business of cookie making!!
Dry ingredients looking all...ummm dry.....
Almost looks like peanut butter and chocolate. (but it isn't....honest...well, other than the chocolate)
Using my favourite spoon, I added the dry mixture to the wet. This spoon is great for scooping the dry ingredients into the bowl.
Job well done, spoon. Though I have to say, it seems like there is way too much of the dry mixture for the amount of wet.
Umm....not to be a baking alarmist, but look at this dough.
Looks more like dirt (dry dirt, not the fancy mud pie variety). It would be wrong to blame my favourite spoon. (right?)
Seriously, this is some dry looking dough. Not sure about this at all. Should a cookie dough be like this??
Does anyone else hear those alarms going off? It's just inside my head, isn't it?
Perhaps chilling it in the fridge will have a positive affect on the dough.
I just have a bad, bad feeling about this....like a 'Sheriff there's a body in the water' bad feeling. (line from Twin Peaks....always seems to be floating around in my head) That's normal, right? (unlike this dough)
So even though I had a bad feeling about this cookie dough, I went ahead and baked up a batch. And sure enough, the dough was still dry when I rolled it out. And once baked....you guessed it, dry.
Well, what do you do when life gives you a dry cookie? Why make another batch of cookies of course!! But unlike my usual course of action -- making the same recipe twice -- I am going to try another recipe.
This cookie is one that Matt wrote about on their Baked website. He calls them the Tarmac cookies. And they look so chocolatey and awesome. Surely these cookies won't let me down.
And here is the lovely dough. Now this is a cookie dough I can get behind! Can't wait to chill this dough and then get the cookies into the oven.
These cookies turned out beautifully. I couldn't ask for a better cookie. The peanut butter combined with the oatmeal and chocolate.......perfect. This cookie is going into the recipe box.
So, today would have been my dad's 91st birthday. Therefore, like my chocolate in this recipe, it is a bittersweet day. I would love to be able to share my baking successes and even failures with my dad (and mom). I know they would have gotten a kick out of my baking and blogging adventures.
So happy birthday Dad....oh and I made oatmeal yesterday....wasn't as good as yours...
My cookie batter looked just like yours. I added 2 Tbsp of butter and it was still too dry, so I added 2 more Tbsp agave nectar (I used up the last of my molasses for the cookies, and agave nectar was the next closest thing in my cupboard). It worked and the cookies were really delicious!ReplyDelete
What a sweet remembrance for your father. I would really like to try those tarmac cookies, myself!
For some reason, my cookie dough came out just fine, as opposed to what most people are saying. Not sure why! Even though you say they were dry, they actually look yummy! The tarmac cookies look great too!ReplyDelete
I guess I got lucky with this recipe, because my dough wasn't dry, either. But kudos to you for sticking with it, and your cookies still look good! (And thanks for the tip on the tarmac cookies -- they look fantastic and I will have to put those on the to-bake list!)ReplyDelete
Sorry your cookies did not cooperate, but I'm happy to see your not-give-up cookies! I just checked out that recipe, per your advice, and I'll be making them soon too...thanks!ReplyDelete
Great blog, Sandra! Today is my grandma's birthday and my best friend just gave birth to a baby boy this morning! A good date for good people, no doubt! I'm going to have to try those Tarmac Cookies now... I think I saw Matt's pic of them on Instagram...?ReplyDelete
It sounds like the second cookies you made turned out a lot better. I passed on this recipe, but if I ever make it in the future I'll have to be cautious of the dry dough.ReplyDelete
I have yet to bake with molasses. I'll have to try your cookies to start!ReplyDelete
I'm glad you showed a picture of your dough because it looked just like mine did! I was so worried about these cookies and thought about making another kind of dough last night, but didn't and ended up liking them. I totally want to try the Tarmac cookies - like right now.ReplyDelete
"(this eye twitch? Oh it's nothing)" haha! My dough seemed a bit dry too, but I added a tablespoon of water and that seemed to help. Those Tarmac cookies sound amazing. As always, really enjoyed your post.ReplyDelete
What a sweet post - sorry about your molasses cookies, but the other ones look great!ReplyDelete